Balance Development Goals

Local actions that concurrently strengthen a community’s infrastructure, economy, and natural environment to advance the sustainability and durability of all three.

Among the most important assets in rural communities are natural resources and built infrastructure. For generations, economic interests across the country have exploited or extracted natural resources from rural areas without long-term planning to ensure those resources would last into and support future generations in those communities. Likewise, significant investment in the maintenance of existing and the building of new infrastructure essential to community and individual well-being – from roads and bridges and buildings and clinics to broadband coverage – has bypassed much of rural America. 

Moreover, the resulting environmental, health, and economic costs have overwhelmingly fallen on the poorest and BIPOC populations in rural communities. To have enduring and equitable prosperity, rural communities must act to connect (and steadily improve) their natural resources and built environment with their economic viability both today and for future generations.

Building Block Evidence

Evidence indicates that this building block is important because of the integrated nature of ecosystems, development, economic opportunities, and human well-being.1 As part of the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment (MEA), Duraiappah and colleagues1 explored different ways societies respond to or intervene in the management of their natural ecosystems, including legal, economic, behavioral, and technological, and further examined the impact and consequences of those responses on ecosystem services, well-being, and poverty reduction. Policies and practices implemented in any of these areas will have different benefits, risks, and burdens for different groups of people, and the impact may happen in the future and possibly not even in the immediate geographic location.

Assessments of the WealthWorks program — a program focused on building multiple forms of wealth/capital, including economic, social, and natural, that makes locally-informed, system-wide investments of resources, skill building, and policy work in rural communities and regions — point to the benefits of models that attend to both economic and environmental outcomes. Their work is focused on building value chains, or “a set of relationships among the people and businesses whose skills and contributions are essential to produce a good or service valued by buyers in the market”.2, p.7 An assessment of their capacity building efforts with multiple community and economic development organizations demonstrates positive economic and environmental outcomes through the development of value chains in energy efficiency retrofitting, biofuel production, local food producers’ access to wholesale buyers, grass-fed beef, and access to Forest Stewardship Council certification to support stewarding and sales of sustainably harvested trees.2 

Efforts are increasing to implement strategies aligned with a Just Transition – “the idea that justice and equity must form an integral part of the transition towards a low-carbon world” and that framing jobs versus the environment as a binary choice inhibits possibilities for “a more profound transition that could transform the economic and political structures that reproduce and exacerbate inequalities and power asymmetries”.3, p.3-4 The evidence for Just Transition efforts is emerging and mainly consists of case studies and descriptions of projects (for case study examples, see UNRISD 2018, Just Transition Initiative, Just Transition Centre 2017).3-5 Studies of the work of the economic transition team of Alliance for Appalachia indicated that there were successful Just Transition initiatives happening across the region.6,7 Active participants in those initiatives identify the need for more appropriate and useful policies and more multisectoral support, as they report feeling supported by community-based organizations but not by the government in their efforts.

With regard to understanding the impact of the green economy or green jobs, the sunsetting of the Bureau of Labor Statistics’ Green Goods and Services survey (BLS GGS) has hampered the already challenging task of measuring the impact of the green economy in the US.8 Many analyses of the green economy still draw upon older data from the BLS project, combining them with other data sets. One estimate that draws from the Low Carbon and Environmental Goods and Services Sector (LCEGSS) and multiple other data sets found that the green economy represents $1.3 trillion in annual sales revenue and employs 9.5 million people on a full-time basis, which represents about 4% of working age adults.8

  1. Duraiappah et al. 2005
  2. Yellow Wood-WealthWorks 2015
  3. UNRISD 2018
  4. Just Transition Initiative
  5. Just Transition Centre 2017
  6. Tarus et al. 2017
  7. Taylor et al. 2017
  8. Georgeson & Maslen 2019

Curated ReSources

People in boat white water rafting
Rural Outdoor Recreation Economies

Tourism and outdoor recreation are driving new opportunities for local communities in many rural places. Analysis of recent news articles and solutions shared with Aspen CSG by rural practitioners provide perspective on how to do economic development differently with rural recreation economies.

People walking with children on their shoulders
Naturally Balanced: What does it take to steward the land and grow rural prosperity?

Rural and Native communities have been stewarding the land for generations. Many are using new ways of growing nature and…

Environmental Justice Practices & Resources for Rural Communities

New efforts focused on environmental justice, just transitions, corporate stakeholder engagement, scientific conservation efforts, and Indigenous wisdom are helping balance natural ecosystems and strengthen local communities.

Pathfinders: Climate-Smart Solutions from Rural America and Native Nations

Jul. 7th, 2022, 2PM

Drought and wildfire in the West, rising seas and erosion in the Mississippi River Delta, and erratic weather patterns throughout…

Place Matters: Suiting Climate Solutions to Rural Regions

A recent New York Times article detailed the climate-related pros and cons of using wood pellets for heating in the Southeast United…

America’s Rural Opportunity: Towards Rural Resiliency

As our changing climate and lopsided growth increase risks for people and places, some rural communities, even as they respond to these challenges, are preparing and looking for opportunity. Strategies deployed today can adapt to and mitigate both climate and economic threats – and produce multiplier resiliency effects.

America’s Rural Opportunity: Tension as Catalyst

Learn about what they have done to forge new productive partnerships and about the difference it has made for the economy and environment, as well as rural communities and livelihoods.

Field Items

Economic Development Success Stories

Head over to the WealthWorks to read success stories from communities from across the country.

Ensuring an Equitable Just Transition

RMI presents a comprehensive review of state legislation that supports coal communities and workers facing economic transition mapped onto our policy framework.

Just Transition Fund

The Just Transition Fund is on a mission to create economic opportunity for the frontline communities and workers hardest hit by the transition away from coal.

Rural Voices for Conservation Coalition

RVCC is committed to finding and promoting solutions through collaborative, place-based work that recognizes the inextricable link between the long-term health of the land and the well-being of rural communities.

We see the framework as a living document, which necessarily must evolve over time, and we seek to expand the collective ownership of the Thrive Rural Framework among rural equity, opportunity, health, and prosperity ecosystem actors. Please share your insights with us about things the framework is missing or ways it should change.

Aspen Institute Community Strategies Group